Comment: Mel Gibson's Jesus movie sparks controversy

By Peter T. Chattaway

THE PASSION, Mel Gibson's much-hyped movie about the events leading to the death of Christ, won't be coming to theatres near us for nearly a year; Gibson plans to release it in time for Easter 2004. But the controversy over his film is already under way -- and people are taking sides in the debate even though no one has yet seen the finished film.

Paula Fredriksen, a historian and a member of the ad hoc group of mostly Catholic and Jewish scholars who analyzed the film's screenplay, writes in the latest issue of The New Republic that Gibson's film, which is said to be the goriest Jesus movie ever made, takes some of its more "lurid" elements from the visions of an 18th-century nun. Fredriksen warns these elements could promote anti-semitism, whether they are meant to or not.

Four of Fredriksen's colleagues, who are all members of the Catholic church's advisory committee on Jewish-Catholic relations, have also posted their concerns regarding the screenplay on the website of Boston College, a Jesuit institution.

Others have lined up to defend the film, a rough cut of which Gibson has shown to conservative politicians, pundits and religious leaders like Rush Limbaugh, David Horowitz and Matt Drudge. Ted Haggard, president of the National Association of Evangelicals, told the Colorado Springs Gazette the film depicted Jesus "more accurately than any other film," and Focus on the Family president Don Hodel called the film "historically and theologically accurate."

Similarly, Gibson has said his film will be the most accurate depiction of the death of Christ ever made -- he told one reporter that watching it would be like "travelling back in time and watching the events unfold exactly as they occurred." He has even claimed a measure of divine inspiration for his film, telling his audience in Colorado Springs, "The Holy Ghost was working through me on this film, and I was just directing traffic."

Who should we believe? Everyone who has seen the film or read the script has had to sign a confidentiality agreement, so very few specific details have leaked out. And of course, the editing of the film is not yet complete.

But now that the trailer for The Passion has been released on the internet, we know that the film is not quite as authentic as many people have said it is. In some ways, it's a step backwards for Jesus films, many of which, over the past three decades, have gone out of their way to get as many of the details historically accurate as possible.

In 1977, Franco Zeffirelli's mini-series Jesus of Nazareth depicted Jesus carrying a crossbeam, and not the entire cross, through the streets of Jerusalem. In 1979, Campus Crusade's Jesus had the nails go through his wrists, not the palms of his hands. And in 1988, Martin Scorsese's The Last Temptation of Christ showed how the Romans crucified their victims naked -- a fact that was recognized by the early church, even if later religious art tended to cover it up. (St. Cyril of Jerusalem said early Christians were baptized in the nude partly in imitation of Christ's death.)

But in Gibson's film, Jesus carries the whole cross and is crucified with a cloth around his loins and nails through his palms. In addition, the film's Pontius Pilate pronounces his Latin as though he were a modern Catholic and not an ancient Roman -- and never mind that the historical Pilate almost certainly would have spoken to the Jews in Greek.

What does come through in the trailer is that Gibson's film will be very violent, but that is to be expected from an actor and director whose career, from the Lethal Weapon franchise to the Oscar-winning Braveheart, has tended to dwell on scenes of pain and torture more than most. Gibson, who belongs to a traditionalist Catholic sect that rejects the authority of the Pope and practises its liturgy in Latin, seems to be interested not so much in historical accuracy, but in making the bloodiest medieval passion play of all time.

We will have to wait to see how Gibson makes use of this violence in his film. Still, just as some critics have expressed concern over the fetishization of explicit violence in increasingly gory war movies like Saving Private Ryan, Black Hawk Down and Gibson's own We Were Soldiers, we too should be cautious about praising a Jesus film just because it gives us more blood and guts.

Already I have heard someone say that, based on the trailer, The Passion is not grisly enough, and no doubt some other director will try to out-do it some day. If Gibson's film is to be any good -- and I do hope it is -- it will have to be more than simply the goriest Jesus ever made . . . so far.

Related stories:

The Passion of Mel Gibson
His Jesus film is bloody, bold -- and in Aramaic. Here's an exclusive look
Time, January 19

A very violent 'passion'
Mel Gibson's movie about the last hours in the life of Jesus Christ is his riskiest yet
Holly McClure, New York Daily News, January 26

The Greatest Story, Newly Told
Mel Gibson on "The Passion," and the passion behind it.
Wall Street Journal, March 7

LA Rabbi Asks Mel Gibson to Reconsider Jesus Film
A prominent Jewish leader on Friday asked actor Mel Gibson to make certain that his new film on the last 12 hours in the life of Christ does not portray the Jews as collectively responsible for the crucifixion.
Variety, March 8

Is the Pope Catholic . . . Enough?
In these films, but especially in a new movie, a monumentally risky project called "The Passion," which he co-wrote and is currently directing in and around Rome, Gibson appears increasingly driven to express a theology only hinted at in his previous work. That theology is a strain of Catholicism rooted in the dictates of a 16th-century papal council and nurtured by a splinter group of conspiracy-minded Catholics, mystics, monarchists and disaffected conservatives -- including a seminary dropout and rabble-rousing theologist who also happens to be Mel Gibson's father.
New York Times Magazine, March 9

Mel Gibson Denies Jesus Film Is Anti-Semitic
Actor Mel Gibson, breaking his silence on his controversial film depicting the last 12 hours in the life of Jesus Christ, denied on Friday that his movie was anti-Semitic and insisted the film is "meant to inspire, not offend."
Variety, June 13

Mel Gibson brings movie to city's church leaders
Actor Mel Gibson has been getting closer to God. On Thursday, that led him to Colorado Springs, where he visited New Life Church and Focus on the Family and previewed his upcoming film, "The Passion."
Colorado Springs Gazette, June 28

Mel Gibson looks right for movie on Jesus
Filmmaker Mel Gibson, whose upcoming movie on the last 12 hours in the life of Jesus has drawn charges of anti-Semitism from Jewish and Catholic scholars, is shopping his film to a more receptive audience: evangelical Christians, conservative Catholics and Orthodox Jews.
Washington Times, July 7

Capturing the Passion
A new film by Mel Gibson, to be released next year, depicts Jesus' last few hours. Jews and Catholics are raising concerns about its potential for stoking anti-Semitism.
Christian Science Monitor, July 10

Gibson's passionate movie critics have cross to bear
There's nothing like antagonistic opposition, based on dirty tricks and disinformation, and then unmasked, to cast a favourable light on something or somebody. Mel Gibson's forthcoming movie about the Passion and death of Jesus Christ -- with dialogue in Latin and Aramaic without subtitles -- has benefited considerably from such opposition.
Frank Devine, The Australian, July 11

Internet reveals Gibson's brutal vision of Jesus
It looks set to be the most brutal and confrontational depiction of the story of Jesus's last days ever filmed. The first trailer of Mel Gibson's controversial version of the final days of Christ, called The Passion, was released over the internet yesterday with explicit images.
Herald, July 15

Mad Mel
An inside look at Mel Gibson's anti-historical, anti-intellectual, anti-Semitic film about the crucifixion.
Paula Fredriksen, The New Republic, July 17

Anti-Semitic notion of Passion won't go away
The Jewish people did not kill Jesus, despite what Mel Gibson's new movie might suggest. Civic and religious leaders conspired to crucify him.
Steve Gushee, Palm Beach Post, July 18

'Passion' elicits unfair conflict
Any piece of pop culture that touches on serious religious themes inspires its share of controversy, but the noisy assaults on Mel Gibson's unfinished film The Passion, which describes the final 12 hours in the life of Jesus Christ, seem unfair and painfully premature.
Michael Medved, USA Today, July 21

Mel Gibson's Washington power play
Movie star Mel Gibson -- under fire from Jewish groups and religious scholars for his still-unreleased film that graphically portrays the crucifixion of Jesus -- yesterday screened a two-hour rough cut of "The Passion" for a select group of Washington pundits, clergymen, cybergossip Matt Drudge and Hollywood lobbyist Jack Valenti, and at least one White House staffer.
Lloyd Grove, Washington Post, July 22

Gibson's film about Jesus raises Jews' fears
Forget about "Mad Max" and "Lethal Weapon." Mel Gibson is now trading on his celebrity to complete the most personal and provocative project of his career: a graphic depiction of the last 12 hours of the life of Jesus Christ.
New York Daily News, July 22

Is Mel Gibson's film passion for Jesus misplaced?
Making a movie about Christ is a surefire path to instant publicity, most of it negative. And when one of the most bankable stars in the English-speaking world is backing the project, you can bet Christ won't go quietly this time.
Alex Beam, Boston Globe, July 22

Mel Gibson's 'The Passion'
I saw a movie this week that moved me, changed me, inspired me and deepened my faith.
Joseph Farah, WorldNetDaily.com, July 23

Old hatred, new Passion
Though the controversy over Mr. Gibson's Passion is increasingly being portrayed as a battle between the superstar director and Jewish critics, the fundamental conflict is between Mr. Gibson and the Roman Catholic Church.
Abraham Cooper and Harold Brackman, Globe and Mail, July 24

Mel's Passion
What's liberal about judging Gibson's movie before it's out?
Editorial, Wall Street Journal, July 25

Film rattles religious groups
Controversy greets Gibson's The Passion
The Province, July 27