|
By Lloyd Mackey
 ONE OF the sidelights of the prime minister's visit to a big new mosque in Calgary was the comment from prominent imam Syed Soharwardy, that the mosque was the spiritual home of what he described as a Muslim "Mormon" movement.
Soharwardy is the president of the Islamic Supreme Council of Canada and head of Muslims Against Terrorism.
He received a fair amount of ink a few months ago by trying to take Western Standard publisher Ezra Levant to the Alberta Human Rights Commission. His action was aimed at WS for publishing the controversial Danish cartoons irreverently depicting the Prophet Mohammed.
Almost as quickly as he launched the action, Soharwardy withdrew it, suggesting that he had determined belatedly that the AHRC was an inappropriate body to deal with free speech and free press issues.
One can give the imam the benefit of the doubt, perhaps. In trying to be cutting-edge controversial, while at the same time giving leadership to moderate, yet devout, Muslims, he might occasionally stray into modes of leadership and communication that might fly better back in the homeland, than in free-wheeling Alberta.
In re-positioning himself to be both more moderate and more relevant, he runs the risk of a believability gap. In that sense, he is like many religious and political leaders who, as they mature, begin to mellow. They recognize the benefit of giving off more light than heat.
Be that as it may, Soharwardy's "they are our Mormons" comment was most striking, given that Alberta, as it happens, is traditionally both Bible Belt and Mormon country, especially in its southernmost regions.
Evangelical Christians are quick to point out that "Mormons are not real Christians". All the while such Christians allow that the Latter Day Saints (as the Mormon church is more formally identified) are generally good, moral, fine-living and upright people who would make very fine Christians, indeed, if only they would reinterpret the Bible properly and forget this Book of Mormon stuff.
In writing colloquially about differing belief systems, there is a point to be made, with respect to understanding and tolerance.
Like the Mormons, the Ahmadiyya group -- whose mosque Stephen Harper was visiting -- have a "latter day" prophet who takes its followers in a different and, arguably, more contemporary direction than the original founders. The Mormons had Joseph Smith. ÊThe name of the 19th century Ahmadiyya prophet is Mirza Ghulam Ahmad.
* * *
That the prime minister would visit the new $15 million mosque is not surprising. It is in Calgary, and its membership would include many residents of Calgary-Southwest riding, which Harper represents in the House of Commons.
Here is what the PM had to say when he toured the mosque and addressed its people: This community knows first-hand what it is to experience persecution and discrimination based on your religious beliefs.
So you understand at a profound level that promoting religious freedom is an essential building block for peace and stability here and throughout the world. All this takes on some additionally interesting significance when the Calgary mosque visit is juxtapositioned with Harper's address to the Jewish human rights advocacy group, B'nai B'rith, which took place a few days earlier, in Ottawa.
The occasion was B'nai B'rith International's awarding of its highest honour, the Gold Medallion.
Continue article >>
|
Harper is the first Canadian to receive the award. He joins company with past American presidents Harry Truman, Dwight Eisenhower and John Kennedy, former British prime minister Margaret Thatcher and Israeli prime ministers David Ben Gurion and Golda Meir.
Bearing in mind what the prime minister said to the "Muslim Mormons" just days later, it is worth noting his comments to the B'nai B'rith crowd.
He quoted the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, which intones that Canada "is founded upon the principles that recognize the supremacy of God and the rule of law".
And he said the charter "is rooted in our common theistic tradition and the covenant at Sinai."
Harper used that groundwork to note, later, that: We see Israel as a friend and ally in the democratic family of nations.
Our support for her right to exist is unshakeable.
Our support for her right to self-defence, (is) unequivocal. Then, a quick move to a point that might be contended in such an audience:Just as we support a two-state solution in the Middle East.
In this we stand with Israeli leaders who have long desired peace, security and democracy for both their own people and the Palestinians. And a move back to reinforce the original point:And the sweep of history tells us that those groups and regimes who seek the destruction of Israel have not and never will bring victory, peace or justice to the Palestinians. They can only prolong their suffering. Harper has learned quickly, during his short tenure, that a leader in a country as pluralistic as Canada must understand the nuances which bring people together and drive them apart.
* * *
Lloyd Mackey is a member of the Canadian Parliamentary Press Gallery in Ottawa and author of Stephen Harper: The Case for Collaborative Governance (ECW Press, 2006). He can be reached at lmackey@canadianchristianity.com.
Related stories:
Muslims open new house of worship
Calgary's new northeast landmark is Canada's largest mosque
Calgary Herald, June 29
Largest mosque opens in Calgary amid political fanfare
Canada's newest and largest mosque opened Saturday, praised by Prime Minister Stephen Harper as an "architectural treasure." Mr. Harper also strongly defended the Ahmadiyya community -- an offshoot Muslim sect persecuted in some countries -- for building a mosque that demonstrates "the true and benevolent face of Islam."
Canadian Press, July 5
Really big mosque on the prairie
Canada's largest mosque was officially dedicated on Saturday by an estimated crowd of 5,000 people that included religious leaders, Canada's two top politicians and throngs of faithful.
CanWest News Service, July 7
Delta mosque will be one of B.C.'s largest
When Canada's biggest mosque was officially opened in Calgary last weekend, the Ahmadiyya Muslim community announced plans to open a comparably large mosque in Metro Vancouver. The plan calls for a mosque of 25,000 to 30,000 square feet to be built on the 3.8-acre site of a now-demolished school at 9570 River Road in Delta.
Vancouver Sun, July 8
July 10/2008
|
For your kind information, "unanimous opinion" among Muslim scholars today that you refer to is an oxymoron. Muslims today, in accordance to the prophecies of the Holy Prophet (saw) mentioned in Bukhari etc., are in utter chaos. There are more than 73 sects, and none of them agree on even the very basics of Islam. The Sunnis call the Shiites kafir, the Shias call the Sunnis kafir. Brelvis call Deobandis kafir, deobandis call wahabis kafir, and the wahabis call just about everyone else a kafir. There is only one solution to this pathetic state of Islam today: to accept and believe the Promised Messiah (as) and Mehdi (as), i.e. Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad.
Wasalam.
Walid Odeh
Sounds nice but you just have 1 problem, and that is MGA´s book. Here is a nice quote :
"It is possible and quite possible that at some time in future such Messiah may appear upon whom the literal words of Hadith(of Holy Prophet) fit, because this humble self has not come with the Reign and Command of this world, but with poverty and humility."
(Izala-e-Auham, Roohani Khazain vol 3 p.197)
So when he admit himself that he is NOT the real thing, then why even discuss it ??
Nancy
Well said- even the Ahmadi Muslims cannot build a mosque in saudi: Their intolerance goes against the very grain of Islam.
There are many Churches in present day Muslim countries eg Egypt, Syria, Turkey, and Indonesia. This is in line with the freedom of religion given in Islam.
However it is right to note that some countries have gone against this Islamic injunction and prohibited collective worship by non-Muslims. This is wrong and completely unacceptable.
Never did the Prophet Muhammad(peace be upon him) forbid the building of a church, nor did he order the demolition of a church. In fact the Qur’an mentions that Muslims are to defend Churches, and synagogues if they are attacked,
Those who have been driven out from their homes unjustly only because they said, ‘Our Lord is Allah’ – And if Allah did not repel some men by means of others, there would surely have been pulled down cloisters and churches and synagogues and mosques, wherein the name of Allah is oft-commemorated. And Allah will surely help one who helps Him. Allah is indeed Powerful, Mighty. (Holy Qur’an, Ch.22:V.41
The fact that extremists act against this Holy command reflects the extremism of people rather than the tolerance of the faith.
read again the quotation u attribute to the Promised messiah. It appears to be accurate but it is hard to comprehend how u came up with the stated conclusion.