|
By Lloyd Mackey
 AS THE Canadian election campaign gets underway, and the U.S. presidential race steams toward its conclusion, observers have noted key differences in the ways faith is presented publicly in the two countries.
In Canada, Green Party leader Elizabeth May was the subject of a photo in the September 9 Ottawa Citizen showing her donating some organically-grown pumpkins to The Mission -- an Ottawa inner-city ministry to street people, sited virtually within the shadow of the Peace Tower.
The gesture was one of a series of occasional Canadian forays into the world of relating faith and politics. All federal political parties attempt to engage at this level. But to many observers, they appear to do so much more subtly than do their American counterparts.
'Universal' vs. 'Religious'
David Kilgour, recently retired federal cabinet minister and a serious advocate for spiritual input on public policy issues, suggests some reasons for the Canadian subtlety. Kilgour co-authored Uneasy Neighbo(u)rs, an exploration of contrasts between Canada and the U.S. He says Canada's lower religious commitment profile causes politicians to use "universal" terminology, rather than "religious" language, when dealing with potentially contentious values-based issues.
The sense with many politicians is that "if you are open to one faith, you will draw hostility from other faiths who feel they are being left out," Kilgour explains, adding that elected representatives "don't want to [be seen to] represent only some of the people."
Religious nuances
But American politicians, too, can be cautious on such expressions, Kilgour adds, noting that such caution goes back to president Abraham Lincoln, who "really understood different religious motivations and nuances and was never exclusionary. He was able to have a resonance with many faith communities."
However, Kilgour allows that, in Lincoln's day, religious diversity was limited basically to Protestant and Catholic Christianity; whereas present day Canada's populace includes increasing numbers of non-Christian religious groups.
And he points out, as well, that "a politician might be more at ease in using specifically religious language in, say, Abbotsford, than in mid-town Toronto."
Elizabeth May -- who hopes one day to be ordained as an Anglican minister -- likes to make the point that many Christians are prepared to give a nod to issues that aren't necessarily perceived as 'socially conservative,' such as the need to save the planet.
She makes the point because mainstream media coverage often leaves the clear impression, in both the United States and Canada, that there is a symbiosis which ties the political and religious right together.
The Palin factor
That perception has been heightened in the U.S. by the addition of Alaska governor Sarah Palin to the Republican ticket, as John McCain's vice presidential running mate. Palin represents many things which seemed to be needed on that ticket, not the least of which was the rounding up of evangelical support for the Republicans.
The possible downside of that support is the logical desire of mainstream media to dig into Palin's church background, which some of her critics decided exhibited a theocratic bent.
Throughout her life, Palin has been associated with Pentecostal or charismatic churches that help to shape the culture and politics of life in small town Alaska. It was not hard to find clips showing clergy friends of the Palin family who reference a biblical quote about "the ends of the earth" and portray it as a prophetic portrayal of God's future blessing on Alaska.
Biblical rhetoric
Some Christians are inclined to dramatize biblical or historically religious references to encourage the involvement of people of faith in the political process.
In Canada, the particular text they draw upon is the psalm declaring that God "shall have dominion from sea to sea." Christian leaders bringing tour groups to the Peace Tower often pray that God will soon fulfill prophecy, bring his dominion to Canada and publicly anoint the leader of his choosing.
A wide range of serious Canadian Christians take encouragement from the "dominion" reference. But most see the kingdom of God as being established in people's hearts, more than in the legislative chambers. They would suggest that when people pray and fellowship together, they draw strength. And they believe that those who are politically active among them will allow their faith to shape the influences they bring to bear on public policy issues.
New approaches
To that end, a September 6 analysis in the National Post is instructive. The piece deals with new approaches being taken to one of the issues considered most crucial to socially conservative Christians; it was written by David Frum -- a Canadian conservative analyst who works with an American think tank, the American Enterprise Institute.
Entitled 'The new (softer) face of pro-life,' the article pointed out that when Palin made her acceptance speech at the Republican National Convention, she "welcomed her family onto the stage: her husband, her five children and the fiance of Bristol, her visibly pregnant 17-year-old daughter."
Noted Frum: "That moment confirmed a dramatic evolution in American politics: the transformation of the pro-life movement from an unambiguously conservative force into something more complex."
Unlikely allies
Frum made the following points to defend that thesis: - The pro-life movement is finding new allies in unlikely places.
- It has made cause with the rights of the disabled.
- It has accepted gender equality and leadership roles for women.
- And "most fascinating of all, it has come to terms with the sexual revolution."
Religious groups, he said, have opened some 2,200 crisis pregnancy centres across the United States in recent years. Frum also cited the development of in-school nurseries, so unmarried teenagers who have given birth can keep their children and still attend high school.
Continue article >>
|
The point of Frum's piece is that this broadened approach on the part of the pro-life movement has worked. His proof? Statistics show that "in 1981, 29.3 abortions were carried out for every 1,000 women of childbearing age in the United States. By 2005, that rate has tumbled to 19.1 per 1,000 women."
In other words, abortion, he says, "has been made more rare; unwed motherhood has been normalized. However you feel about that outcome, it is not well-described as either left-wing or right wing."
Related stories:
Green candidate accused of Israel-bashing gets May's support
Green Party Leader Elizabeth May is affirming her support for an Ottawa-area Green Party candidate accused of "Israel bashing," just one day after citing anti-Semitism as grounds for rejecting one of her B.C. candidates.
Globe and Mail, September 5
Sarah Palin: Religious views on Iraq war, pipelines, end of world and more
Gov. Palin should explain her beliefs concerning the inevitability of a cataclysm and the end of time, Gushee said. "To me, it is highly relevant to someone who potentially has her hand on the nuclear button. If that is her worldview, I would want to know about that."
Douglas Todd, The Search, Vancouver Sun, September 5
Tories dole out pre-election cash
Federal Conservatives have sprinkled some pre-election cash across Greater Toronto, with new funding to improve security at local Jewish community organizations and a long-awaited agreement to hand over the funding for Toronto's subway extension. . . . It all comes as Prime Minister Stephen Harper prepares to seek the consent of Governor General Michalle Jean tomorrow to dissolve Parliament for an Oct. 14 election. But that day is also the Jewish religious holiday Succot. Yesterday, Harper called Rabbi Reuven Bulka, co-president of the Canadian Jewish Congress, to discuss the decision for calling the election on a key date in the Jewish calendar.
Toronto Star, September 6
B'nai Brith regrets but understands why Harper set election on Jewish holiday
"Prime Minister Harper has personally reached out to the Jewish community and contacted B'nai Brith regarding his decision to hold the upcoming federal election on a date that falls on a Jewish holiday," said Frank Dimant, executive vice-president of B'nai Brith Canada. . . . He said new electoral laws would allow voters to cast their ballot on days other than the scheduled election date.
National Post, September 6
The new (softer) face of America's pro-life movement
Whoever imagined that we would see a Republican convention rapturously applaud an unwed teen mother? Yet that is just what happened on Wednesday night in St. Paul. At the conclusion of Sarah Palin's triumphant speech, the Alaskan Governor welcomed her family onto the stage: her husband, her five children and the fiance of Bristol, her visibly pregnant 17-year-old daughter. That moment confirmed a dramatic evolution in American politics: the transformation of the pro-life movement from an unambiguously conservative force into something more complex.
David Frum, National Post, September 6
Duceppe queries Opus Dei candidate
Bloc Quebecois Leader Gilles Duceppe said today the Conservative candidacy of a former Opus Dei spokeswoman is a sign of the governing party's narrow-minded views and attempts to bring right-wing religious views into Parliament. Mr. Duceppe quickly jumped on a news report that Nicole Charbonneau Barron, a Conservative candidate in a riding south of Montreal, used to be the public face of the powerful conservative group within the Roman Catholic Church.
Globe and Mail, September 9
Harper lied about cleaning up politics in Ottawa: Duceppe
Earlier Mr. Duceppe seized on the revelation that one of the Conservatives' candidates in Quebec is a member of the strict Catholic group Opus Dei, saying it is proof that Harper's Conservative party is composed of narrow-minded right-wing ideologues who would take away a woman's right to choose.
CanWest News Service, September 9
Playing the family card gets messy
"Family is everything"? Did Stephen Harper's campaign actually say that at the start of the federal election? If so, I can only imagine that an interview with him describing how he juggles work and family as both a working dad and wannabe Conservative majority Prime Minister is not far behind.
Judith Timson, Globe and Mail, September 9
Alaska Shrugs Off Palin's Faith
Sarah Palin, the Alaska Governor, may be the most overtly religious candidate for U. S. vice-president in recent memory, but she comes from the state with one of the lowest levels of interest in religion. John McCain's Republican running mate is a deeply believing Christian with strong evangelical and Pentecostal roots. "There seems to be a paradox," said Courtney Campbell, a professor of religion and culture at Oregon State University.
National Post, September 10
Holiday wish both baffling and bothersome
A Rosh Hashanah card from the Harpers has left one man wondering: How do they know I'm Jewish?
Globe and Mail, September 10
Gay community united in stance against PM: poll
While gay men tend to vote Liberal and lesbians back the NDP, Canada's homosexual population is united in its opposition to the Conservatives, according to a new report. A study conducted by the Laurier Institute for the Study of Public Opinion and Policy (LISPOP) found just 7.3% of homosexual men and 10.4% of gay women supported the Conservatives in the 2006 election. By comparison, 40.7% of straight men and 32.4% of straight women voted for the Conservatives.
National Post, September 10
Why Stephen Harper keeps his evangelical faith very private
Prime Minister Stephen Harper is damned if he does talk about his evangelical beliefs and damned if he doesn't. If he continues to avoid answering questions about his religious convictions, political observers say he appears secretive, like he's hiding something. But, at the same time, most Canadians do not share the moral convictions of his evangelical denomination, the Christian and Missionary Alliance Church.
Douglas Todd, The Search, Vancouver Sun, September 10
Campaign Quebec: Attacking Catholics is OK, but please don't mention the jihad
It is true that members of Opus Dei do not support abortion. On the other hand, Opus Dei members do not sympathize with Hamas and Hezbollah or believe Jews are legitimate targets for terrorism, surely views that are not "generally accepted in Quebec" as well? Which brings me to what should be the actually worrying case of Ms Samira Laouni, the NDP candidate for the riding of Montreal-Bourassa. Some of us in Quebec who keep our eye on activities and players in the Islamic community wonder why Monsieur Duceppe is so fascinated by Ms Charbonneau-Barron's privately held views on abortion, but is not at all exercised by Ms Laouni's enthusiasm for Sharia law and anti-Western agents provocateurs.
Barbara Kay, Full Comment, National Post, September 11
September 11/2008
|
