Anglican split as painful as a divorce
Anglican split as painful as a divorce
Return to digital BC Christian News

By Steve Weatherbe

October 2008
THE worldwide schism plaguing the Anglican church, sparked by debates over homosexuality, has taken a toll on many congregations.  

The tumultuous departure of the majority of the St. Mary’s Metchosin congregation from the Anglican Church of Canada (ACC) in February created a situation akin to the aftermath of a divorce – with hurt feelings, depression and relief all intermingled.

Two sides of a coin: Larry Seyner (above), new priest at St. Mary's Metchosin; and Bud Boomer, one of 130 people who left the church.
So the surviving congregation at St. Mary’s probably couldn’t have done much better for their new priest than the Rev. Dr. Larry Scyner – a retired family therapist and personal counsellor.

“There is shock, disappointment, a real sense of loss,” reports Scyner. “But above all, there is relief.”

Scyner, something of a troubleshooter for the Victoria-based Diocese of British Columbia, says the split left about 30 in the parish, and half a dozen have joined since it occurred – people who had left in the past few years, because of the policies of the majority and the leadership.

“My job is to help them move from loss, sadness and depression to someplace a little healthier. The sad part is the fracturing into two groups of the community. And it has extended into the larger community of Metchosin. People don’t know how to approach people on the other side of the split, how to invite them over to coffee.” He doesn’t know if the wounds will ever heal.

Some members of the congregation have gay children, some dying of AIDS – and these people felt they were getting little support from the majority, says Scyner.

The surviving congregation falls well short of the 100 families which the diocese believes is needed for a self-sustaining parish. Scyner says the congregants know they have to face the alternatives soon – but have consciously put that off while they pull themselves together spiritually and emotionally. “They are planning to plan,” but not now.

The decrease in numbers has meant the abandonment of the annual Blackberry Festival fundraiser.

“We can’t do everything we used to do,” says lifelong member Isobel Tipton. However, the congregation has decided to carry on with a monthly free meal for seniors.

The future for St. Mary’s is far from bleak. The population of Metchosin is starting to grow; and the remaining congregants, strengthened by their experience, are determined to carry on. Many, says Scyner, can trace their membership back several generations in the 150-year-old parish.

Tipton, whose grandparents were married in the parish’s original church – still standing and occasionally in use ­– says the atmosphere in the church has much improved because of the split. “It’s the relief that it’s settled.”

The alternatives are amalgamation (which Scyner says is a no-go), team ministry (with administration and clergy shared with neighbouring parishes), or carrying on independently, with part-time clergy as now.

“I don’t think we’ll disappear,” says Tipton. “I think we’ll get things going. Already people have come back, and more have promised to. People are looking forward to going to church again. I used to get so angry at church, I would threaten to join the Unitarians.”

Continue article >>

Previous article
A tale of three candidates
Next article
Northgate Foursquare: something old, something new
Island Page 2Island Page 3

Meanwhile, a few miles to the east at Lighthouse Christian Academy, the majority who left the ACC over the same-sex marriage issue are “doing very well,” reports layman and 35-year St. Mary’s member Bud Boomer.

The re-formed group, calling itself St. Mary’s Open Gate, claims 130 members – and actually grew over the summer.

“It surprised us,” admits Boomer, “because attendance usually falls off” during the summer months. He attributes the new group’s adherence to scriptures as a key reason the new people were attracted to the congregation.

Boomer says the new group, which is affiliated with the larger group of like-minded congregations called the Anglican Network, comprises largely the younger members of the original congregation – attracted by the charismatic style and modern worship forms introduced when the parish was inspired by the charismatic renewal in Anglicanism 34 years ago.  

The people drawn to the parish subsequently came largely from non-Anglican backgrounds, says Boomer ­– perhaps explaining their willingness to break from the Canadian organization.

Long-time pastor Sharon Hayton and assistant pastor Andrew Hewlett have stayed with the majority, moving with them to the Lighthouse facility.

Boomer says the clean break has “absolutely improved things. We don’t need to talk about the issues that led to the break. We can just move on.”

Boomer affirms that “We still love the people back at St. Mary’s Metchosin. We hope that they flourish, and the church is used for the purpose it was built for.”

The building, and the land it sits on, is indeed a sore point: just 17 years old, and completely paid for, the property now rests with the owner of record, the Diocese of British Columbia. Appeals of similar court decisions across Canada are still pending. They are based on the claim that the larger church organization does not actually own such properties, but merely holds them in trust for the congregation.

St. Mary’s Open Gate isn’t holding its breath, says Boomer, but is planning community outreach in its new home, in a much more populous part of the Capital Region.

Hewlett says the congregation  “can see God’s hand” in the forced move, though most if not all are sad to leave the church they worked so hard to pay for. “But church is people, not a building,” he says.

The church’s new location, within a thriving Christian school and the community of Langford – which is growing much faster than Metchosin – clearly offers fresh opportunities for evangelization, says Hewlett.

“We were always strong on foreign missions, “ he adds. “Here we have an opportunity for evangelism right on our doorstep. We already have our Alpha courses. Now we will be looking for new ways of pounding the pavement.”

October 2008

  Partners & Friends
Advertisements